It’s long been accepted that grass-fed steaks are better for you. But in the past, grass-fed steaks cooked up tough and chewy and could not compare to the taste and tenderness of a good grain-finished steak. In addition, grass-fed steaks sold at a significant premium over grain-fed. Although consumers were happy that grass-fed steaks were better for them, and significantly better for the environment, they yearned for better taste combined with more tenderness.

grass fed steaksThat all seems to be changing quickly. While the average grain-fed cow is slaughtered in 18–20 months, the grass-fed steak is typically slaughtered at 28 months – and sometimes even later. Those extra months of grass feeding develop a fat marbling and rich color that make for a top-notch, tasty steak… very different from the lean, tough meat we were used to before.

Last May, the Wall Street Journal had a fascinating article on grass-fed steaks that included a recipe on how to cook them. I have repeated it here. This recipe was adapted from “Home Cooked” by Anya Fernald, who owns Belcampo Ranch in California, and Jessica Battilana.

ACTIVE TIME: 25 minutes TOTAL TIME: 1 hour SERVES: 2
1 dry-aged, bone-in rib eye steak,
T-bone, New York strip, porterhouse
or sirloin tip, about 1 ½ inches thick,
with strip of fat intact
1 tablespoon of butter (optional)
Large crystal salt, kosher or sea salt for serving

  1. Remove steak from refrigerator 30 minutes – 1 hour before cooking.
  2. Set a cast-iron pan big enough to cook steak without crowding over high heat and let it sit on heat until very hot and smoke is quickly rising off pan, 3–5 minutes.
  3. Pat steak dry with a paper towel. Add steak to pan, gently pressing down with fingers or a spatula. Sear 1 minute, then flip and sear opposite side 1 minute.
  4. Use tongs to gently hold steak upright and spend about 2 minutes searing edges all around, as well as fat cap, bone and any red exposed flesh on sides.
  5. Turn off heat and let steak rest in pan, 2 minutes each side.
  6. Transfer steak to cutting board, invert cast-iron pan over meat and let rest 10 minutes. A well-marbled steak doesn’t need much of garnish, though a pat of butter is a nice touch. Add butter after you transfer meat to cutting board so it has time to melt and mix with meat’s juices.
  7. Just before serving, slice steak against the grain. Serve with salt, for seasoning to taste at the table.

Try this recipe with one of the certified grass-fed steaks available at Profeta Farms. You won’t be disappointed!

Signup to receive updates to our blog, Organic Matters

Paul Profeta

Paul Profeta

Paul V. Profeta is a visionary who co-founded of Profeta Farms along with his wife, certified Integrative Nutrition Coach Joanne Milano. A serial entrepreneur and successful businessman, Paul became focused on our food supply and the contaminants therein. Eventually, Paul and Joanne decided that America had to change the way it fed itself, and Profeta Farms was born. Committed to growing, raising and selling delicious food that is healthier for our customers and for the environment, Profeta Farms caters to customers who want organic produce, meats, eggs and prepared foods that are fresher, healthier and more flavorful than food from conventional grocery stores or other markets.

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Subscribe To Our Newsletter

Join our mailing list to receive the latest news and updates from our team.

You have Successfully Subscribed!